NotebookLM With New Modes Can Critique Your Work

Published on

One of my favorite AI tools, Google’s NotebookLM, keeps evolving, and the latest update made its “podcasts” even better.

For those who don’t know it, this is the feature that turns a PDF, text, or any sources you upload into a kind of podcast, with AI voices discussing the topic in a really natural way. In my opinion, it’s the best tool out there for studying.

Until now we only had one “standard” podcast style, but Google just introduced three new formats that are pretty interesting.

The new modes are:

  • Brief: For when you need a quick, straight-to-the-point summary. A single voice sums up the main ideas of your material in 1 or 2 minutes. It can be useful for reviewing a presentation before a meeting and things like that.

  • Critique: This one is brilliant if you produce content. Two AI voices analyze your material (blog post, article, report, etc.) and give you constructive feedback, pointing out strengths and areas for improvement. Extremely useful before you click “Publish” or send that report to your boss.

  • Debate: In this mode, two AI voices take opposing sides of a topic in your sources and build a debate, with arguments and counterarguments. It’s reeeally impressive and useful for digging deep into a subject and understanding different perspectives.

  • Deep Dive: This is the format that already existed, a deeper, more collaborative conversation about the topics.

I LOVED the new features! Being able to listen to a debate about your own notes or get a structured critique of your work is something I see as having enormous potential.

In the video below, I uploaded one of my articles (a tutorial on quantization, about how to run open AI models locally on your computer) to NotebookLM, and generated 3 podcasts: one in “Brief” mode, one in “Critique”, and one in “Debate”. It came out too long for the allowed size, so I cut the Critique and the Debate in half, but you can still get a good idea of how they work. The timestamps for each one are:

  • Brief: from the start until 02:07
  • Critique: from 02:11 until 08:02
  • Debate: from 08:06 until the end

If you have the patience to listen to all of it, let me know what you think!