Between Wisdom and the Wall: The Fine Line of Gatekeeping in AI
Published on
I’ve noticed a slightly worrying trend in some conversations with more Senior AI and Data Science professionals.
We know that, with years on the road in this crazy and fascinating field, it’s natural, through a lot of effort, to accumulate plenty of knowledge and a hugely valuable critical eye. It can also seem natural to have strong opinions, coming from all that experience.
But here’s the thought: isn’t it also worth being a little careful so that all that experience doesn’t turn, even unintentionally, into a form of “gatekeeping”? (In other words: the fact of, even unintentionally, “guarding the gates” of knowledge, maybe because you lived through a time when learning all of this required years of formal study and hard-to-acquire experience.)
And the point isn’t even whether the intention is to do this “gatekeeping” or not, but how your actions and your communication can be perceived by people who have less time on the job, or who come from a different field with a fresh perspective.
Again, it’s understandable, especially after going through a hard road of building expertise in statistics, programming, hours debugging models that wouldn’t converge… It can be hard to see someone wanting to enter the field after a 3-month bootcamp 😅
But there’s a crucial difference between showing off your hard-earned knowledge and practicing “gatekeeping”, and sometimes that line is thinner than we’d like to admit. What I’ve noticed at times is that, in the eagerness to “protect the profession”, it can happen that people put up unnecessary barriers.
Phrases like “you’re not a real Data Scientist if you don’t understand X”, “if you haven’t been through Y, you’ll never really understand this field”, or “where were you X years ago? I was already building XYZ models” are some of the red flags in this sense that I’ve seen out there, and that can, even unintentionally, end up signaling to those without all that background that this person cares more about some supposed status than about helping the community grow.
The AI field evolves at an absurd speed, and creating an environment where people feel safe to ask questions, give opinions (even wrong ones at first), and experiment (and even fail!) is essential so we don’t let knowledge stay restricted to small circles.
I think those of us who have some space in this field have the chance (and maybe the responsibility?) to be mentors, to share not only the “what”, but the “why” and the “how”, in an accessible way, emphasizing the important fundamentals without creating unnecessary obstacles, and to recognize that there are many valid paths to becoming a good professional in the field.
At the end of the day, the real test of a Senior professional isn’t only how much knowledge you’ve accumulated, but how you nurture the next generation of talent. It’s about leaving the ladder extended behind you, not pulling it up.
What’s your take on this? Have you felt this barrier (on either side)?